When you hear "Eames lounge chair," you probably think of the iconic mid-century modern design by Charles and Ray Eames. But if you've searched for it, you might have noticed Room and Board—a popular American furniture retailer—offering their own versions. Are they the same? Which one should you buy? This guide breaks down the key differences, costs, quality, and practical advice to help you decide without wasting money or regretting your purchase.
1. Understanding the Original Eames Lounge Chair
The Eames lounge chair (model 670) and ottoman (671) were designed in 1956 by Charles and Ray Eames for Herman Miller. It's a certified classic, known for its molded plywood shell, leather upholstery, and die-cast aluminum base. Genuine versions are made by Herman Miller (in the US) and Vitra (in Europe). Prices start around $5,500 and can exceed $7,000 depending on wood finish and leather type. Key points:
- Authentic design: Licensed by the Eames family, exact proportions, and high-quality materials.
- Durability: Built to last decades with proper care. Many owners pass them down.
- Resale value: Holds value well; used chairs often sell for 60-80% of retail.
- Comfort: Ergonomically designed to cradle your body. The shock mounts (rubber connectors) provide a slight bounce.
Common pitfalls: Buying counterfeit versions on Amazon or eBay that look similar but use cheap materials and have poor comfort. Always buy from an authorized dealer.
2. Room and Board Lounge Chairs: What They Offer
Room and Board is a US-based retailer known for quality American-made furniture. They don't sell the authentic Eames chair, but they offer their own lounge chairs inspired by mid-century design. Their most popular models include the Andes and Remi chairs. Prices range from $1,500 to $3,000.
- Materials: Solid wood frames, high-density foam cushions, and top-grain leather or fabric options. Not molded plywood like the Eames.
- Construction: Made in the USA with a focus on sustainability. Room and Board uses FSC-certified wood and eco-friendly finishes.
- Comfort: Generally plush and supportive, but the feel is different—more like a traditional armchair with a reclining mechanism (some models).
- Warranty: Excellent customer service and a satisfaction guarantee. They offer free design help and easy returns.
Comparison to Eames: Room and Board chairs are not Eames replicas; they are original designs. They lack the iconic look and historical cachet but are often more affordable and still high-quality.
3. Head-to-Head Comparison: Price, Quality, and Comfort
Let's put them side by side on key factors:
| Factor | Eames Lounge Chair (Herman Miller) | Room and Board Lounge Chair |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $5,500 - $7,000+ | $1,500 - $3,000 |
| Materials | Molded plywood, premium leather, cast aluminum | Solid wood, foam, top-grain leather or fabric |
| Comfort | Firm but supportive, ergonomic | Plush, softer, more like a traditional armchair |
| Durability | Extremely durable (20+ years) | Very durable (10-15 years with care) |
| Resale Value | High (60-80% after 10 years) | Moderate (40-60% after 10 years) |
| Style | Iconic mid-century modern | Modern with mid-century hints |
Which is more comfortable? It depends on your body and preference. The Eames chair is designed for leaning back and relaxing; its fixed angle encourages a specific posture. Room and Board chairs often have adjustable recline and thicker cushioning, which some find more cozy. Test both in person if possible.
4. How to Choose: Practical Buying Guide
Follow these steps to decide:
- Set your budget: If you can spend $5,500+, consider the authentic Eames. If not, Room and Board offers great value under $3,000.
- Decide on style: Do you want the exact Eames look? Only the original will do. If you want a modern lounge chair, Room and Board has many options.
- Check dimensions: Eames chair is compact (about 32"W x 32"D x 31"H). Room and Board chairs may be larger. Measure your space.
- Test comfort: Visit a showroom. Sit in both for 10-15 minutes. Notice pressure points, back support, and how easy it is to get up.
- Consider warranty: Herman Miller offers a 12-year warranty. Room and Board offers a limited lifetime warranty on frames and 5 years on cushions.
- Look for sales: Room and Board rarely discounts, but Herman Miller authorized dealers occasionally offer 15-20% off during promotions.
Newbie mistakes to avoid:
- Buying a cheap knockoff online—it will fall apart and hurt your back.
- Ignoring leather quality: Eames uses aniline leather that ages beautifully; cheaper leathers may crack.
- Not considering maintenance: The Eames chair requires occasional conditioning; Room and Board leather may need less care.
5. Real Buyer Recommendations
Here's what actual owners say (based on reviews and forums):
- For design purists: "I bought the Eames and it's worth every penny. It's an investment piece that transforms my living room." – Mark, Chicago
- For comfort seekers: "I compared both and chose the Room and Board Andes because it's softer and I can nap in it. The Eames was too firm for me." – Sarah, Seattle
- For budget-conscious: "Room and Board gave me a beautiful chair for half the price. It's my favorite spot to read." – Tom, Austin
- For long-term investment: "I bought a used Eames for $3,000 and it's still perfect after 5 years. Resale value is unreal." – Lisa, New York
Final tip: Don't rush. Both brands have excellent customer service. Order fabric/leather samples and take your time. A lounge chair is a big purchase—choose the one that fits your lifestyle, not just your decor.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Does Room and Board sell the authentic Eames lounge chair?
A: No. Room and Board sells their own designs. For the authentic Eames, you must buy from Herman Miller or an authorized dealer.
Q: Is the Room and Board chair as durable as the Eames?
A: Both are durable, but the Eames is built to last longer (20+ years vs 10-15). The Eames uses molded plywood and shock mounts, which are more resilient.
Q: Can I get the Eames look for less?
A: You can find replicas online, but quality is inconsistent. Room and Board offers a similar aesthetic with better construction than cheap replicas.
Q: Which chair is better for small spaces?
A: The Eames chair is more compact. Room and Board chairs tend to be bulkier. Measure your room before buying.
Q: Do either chairs go on sale?
A: Herman Miller sales are rare but possible through dealers. Room and Board has a clearance section but rarely discounts new items.
Ultimately, the choice between an Eames lounge chair and a Room and Board lounge chair comes down to your priorities: iconic design and investment value vs. affordability and plush comfort. Both are excellent options—just pick the one that feels right for you.