When it comes to furnishing your home, two names often come up: Burlington and Crate & Barrel. While Burlington is known for deep discounts on brand-name items, Crate & Barrel offers curated designs with a higher price tag. But which one is right for you? This guide breaks down the key differences, helps you avoid common mistakes, and gives actionable steps to shop smart.
Price vs. Value: Where Does Your Money Go?
Burlington operates as an off-price retailer, meaning you can find furniture and decor at 20-60% off traditional retail prices. They carry overstock and closeout items from brands like Ashley Furniture and Sealy. Crate & Barrel, on the other hand, designs its own products and sells them at full price, though sales happen seasonally. For example, a sofa at Burlington might cost $400-$800, while a comparable style at Crate & Barrel could be $1,200-$2,500. The catch: Burlington’s inventory changes constantly, so you might not find matching pieces later. Crate & Barrel offers consistent collections and better warranties.
Quality Check: Materials and Construction
At Burlington, inspect items carefully. Many sofas use particleboard frames and polyester upholstery, which can sag after a few years. Look for hardwood frames and high-density foam cushions. Crate & Barrel typically uses kiln-dried hardwood frames and offers options like performance fabrics that resist stains. For dining tables, Burlington might have veneers over MDF, while Crate & Barrel often uses solid wood. A quick test: lift the corner of a sofa – heavier usually means better construction. Avoid anything that feels wobbly or has thin cushions.
Style Selection: Trends vs. Timeless
Burlington’s selection is hit-or-miss. You might find a trendy accent chair one week, but nothing the next. It’s great for eclectic or temporary pieces. Crate & Barrel focuses on modern, minimalist designs that stay relevant longer. If you want a cohesive look, start with Crate & Barrel for key pieces like a sofa or bed, then fill in with Burlington for lamps, rugs, or throw pillows. Pro tip: measure your space before shopping – Burlington often doesn’t list exact dimensions online, so bring a tape measure.
Practical Steps to Shop Both Stores
1. Make a list of what you need, prioritizing items that get heavy use (sofa, bed, dining table). 2. Visit Crate & Barrel first to see their quality and design standards. Note the materials and dimensions of pieces you like. 3. Go to Burlington with that list in mind. Look for similar styles but inspect for defects like loose seams or scratches. 4. Compare prices: if Burlington is 40% less but similar quality, buy it. If the difference is small, choose Crate & Barrel for better durability. 5. For decor, Burlington is a goldmine – vases, frames, and baskets at 50% off. But skip large furniture unless you’re on a tight budget.
Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them
Mistake 1: Buying a sofa from Burlington without testing it. Sit on it for 10 minutes. Check if the cushions are reversible and if the frame creaks. Mistake 2: Assuming Crate & Barrel is always better. Some items, like dining chairs, are overpriced for what they are. Mistake 3: Ignoring return policies. Burlington has a strict 30-day return with receipt, but Crate & Barrel gives 90 days. Keep all packaging until you’re sure. Mistake 4: Matching everything perfectly. Mixing high-end and budget pieces creates a personalized look. For example, a Crate & Barrel coffee table with Burlington accent chairs.
FAQ
Is Burlington furniture good quality? It varies. Some items are excellent deals from reputable brands, while others are lower-end. Always check the tag for materials and brand name.
Does Crate & Barrel have sales? Yes, they have semi-annual sales in January and July, plus clearance events. Sign up for emails to get 10-15% off.
Can I return furniture to Burlington? Yes, within 30 days with receipt. Items must be in original condition. No returns on mattresses or clearance items.
Which store is better for a full living room set? Crate & Barrel offers coordinated collections. Burlington is best for mixing and matching individual pieces.
How do I know if a sofa will last? Look for a kiln-dried hardwood frame, 8-way hand-tied springs, and high-resilience foam. Avoid particleboard and sinuous springs.
Final Thoughts
Both Burlington and Crate & Barrel have their place in a smart shopping strategy. Use Burlington for accent pieces, decor, and budget-friendly finds. Invest in Crate & Barrel for core furniture that you’ll use daily. Always inspect items in person, measure twice, and keep receipts. With these tips, you can create a beautiful home without overspending.